As Consumer Confidence Falls, Home Sales Rise. It’s a Conundrum.

by Tyler Osby on February 18, 2009

Confidence is Down

Consumer Confidence fell this month for the first time in three months, reflecting Americans’ concern for the economy, housing, and the financial system.  Consumer Confidence

The reading isn’t much of a surprise given our near-constant stream of negative news. Before long, the reports become a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Where There’s Bad News, There’s Good News

Despite falling confidence, the housing industry appears to be recovering.  Sales of existing homes are on the rise and an increasing number of homes are pending (a.k.a under contract to sell).  And, if these statistics seem out of place, consider the other factors that are accompanying this “down” economy:

  • In some markets (not Des Moines), home values have plummeted to early-2000 levels
  • Government intervention has brought mortgage rates to near-5 percent
  • Congress is pledging key support to housing and mortgage markets

Surveys Aren’t Everything

These points can’t be captured in confidence surveys which, by comparison, ignore facts and focus on Big Picture behavioral questions like “Do you think you’ll be better off a year from today?” and “What’s your attitude toward buying major household items?”.  It’s useful information for economists, but not so much for home buyers.  They’re a different breed.

A lot of the country’s housing markets have already started their recovery.  Couple that with the natural momentum of Spring Buying and the stimulus package’s proposed first-time home buyer tax credit and you can clearly see the disconnect.

Remember, Just because consumer confidence is down doesn’t mean that home prices will be too.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: